Shane Samuel Stark was sentenced to life plus 12 years in prison

Alcovy Judicial Circuit District Attorney Randy McGinley reported Monday that, with trial expected to start next week, Shane Samuel Stark had entered a plea of guilty but mentally ill to the murder of his mother, Makhyal Stark Pohlel (Pictured right). His guilty plea also includes numerous aggravated assault and firearm possession charges from firing rounds at law enforcement personnel who had responded to the scene.
The charges were originally filed after Stark called 911 in the early morning hours of Jan. 12, 2022 reporting that he had killed his mother with a shotgun. When numerous deputies with the Walton County Sheriff’s Office, including the SERT team, responded and attempted to enter the home and locate the victim, Stark fired multiple shots at them. He eventually surrendered to law enforcement and was charged.
Follow the indictment, Stark’s attorney asked for a court-ordered mental evaluation to see if he was competent to stand trial and to be held criminally responsible. His defense also commissioned a private evaluation and then advised of their intent to raise the issue of insanity and enter a Special Plea of Not Guilty by Reason of Insanity.
However, with the guilty plea now entered, Stark withdrew the potential of an insanity plea and on Aug. 4 entered the plea of Guilty but Mentally Ill. He was sentenced to Life in Prison plus 12 years.
McGinley explained that a guilty but mentally ill plea and sentence functions essentially the same as a guilty plea. Stark received life in prison and will be in the custody of the Georgia Department of Corrections. McGinley said the department will evaluate Stark and consider any mental health issues when determining appropriate penal facility placement. McGinley said such a plea allows the Department of Corrections more authority in the case of a defendant who suffers from an acute mental health issue to be temporarily transferred to the Department of Behavioral Health and Developmental Disabilities for care in a state mental health facility.
However, if the defendant had proceeded with an insanity defense and a jury found him not guilty by reason of insanity, he would be detained in a state mental health facility to be evaluated for his present mental condition within 30 days. McGinly noted that in such a case, if he were found to meet criteria for involuntary inpatient treatment, he could be kept in a state facility. However, if he did not meet that criteria, he could have been released from custody.
“Cases involving mental health are difficult both factually and legally. I commend the hard work of the prosecution team that led to this outcome of the Defendant accepting responsibility for the murder of his own mother,” McGinley said. “The Defendant has received a sentence of life in prison for his actions, providing some level of closure to the family. I want to personally recognize the SERT team of the Sheriff’s Office who were able to safely apprehend the Defendant while keeping themselves and public safe.”
The case was prosecuted by Assistant District Attorney Tara Murphy, Chief Investigator Josh Chambers, Senior Victim Advocate Donna Brandenburg, and Legal Assistant Heather Johnson. The arrest and investigation were handled by the Walton County GA Sheriff’s Office and the Georgia Bureau of Investigation.

Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.